Stars is also awesome. I recommend In Our Bedroom After the War, although Set Yourself On Fire is also excellent.

Edited to add some more:
City & Colour
Adaline
Au Revoir Simone
Feist
Fleet Foxes
The Swell Season
Iron & Wine (particularly "Around the Well")
Rachael Yamagata (Disc One of "Elephants...Teeth Sinking In")
Ryan Adams ("Love Is Hell")
Sarah Slean
and you can never go wrong with some older Sarah McLachlan (Solace, Fumbling Towards Ecstasy)

Edited By: springyhair 05/31/2010 11:42 PM. Edited 1 times.