HarmonyBear3 wrote:

That's so weird, them supporting the fact that winning doesn't really matter. Like, "Our whole premise is based on who'll be the 'next. American. Idol,' but here's this dude who didn't win to tell you what to do..."

This.

I mean, I don't like Kelly Clarkson but even I know that she's the original American Idol, has had tons of success, and even has a couple of Grammys to her name. They should've asked her back to mentor the kids. But instead they got the dude who came in second, failed to live up to the hype, and hasn't really done anything. This is all for ratings. They don't want to lose to DWTS again.

I completely agree.