I get what you're saying. If he did do it, it's possible that he just got "lucky" (for lack of a better word) that the creek was able to wash away a lot of the blatant physical evidence that could be used in the early '90s? Or that the crackpot investigative team ruined most of the evidence on their own anyway.

The one thing that has always spun me out was the whole Mr Bojangles thing. That whole incident is just mind-blowing in the way that it was handled and how they "lost" the blood that was recovered from the bathroom, and just.. ugh. I'm still to this day so curious about that.

Damien did a Reddit AMA a few months back and I think that someone had asked him about his relationship with Seth now, but I honestly don't remember what he said. Here's the link because I don't feel like reading through all of that right now. (I hope that's where I read it, I honestly don't remember.. but don't get mad at me if it's not in there )