| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 SweetCherry69 |
|||
|
Posts: 3874 (01/25/2009 10:39 PM) |
Hp5010 wrote: That's exactly why I loved POA- because it was so much different from the first two. I liked the first two movies, but they seemed very amateur compared to POA and the rest. Alfonso completely changed the series into something more darker and more entertaining for me. |
||
|
Can Twins Have Two Fathers |
|||
|
Posts: 448 (01/25/2009 11:53 PM) |
blindpilot wrote: Yep. So hot. 
|
||
|
Can Twins Have Two Fathers |
|||
|
Posts: 449 (01/25/2009 11:56 PM) |
Hmm. Can't edit my post.
 |
||
|
Molieshka |
|||
|
Posts: 848 (01/26/2009 12:58 AM) |
Chamber is actually my favorite movie so far. I am a purist to the books and I think the first two were most like the books- mainly b/c the story lines and
length was easier to translate. POA used to be one of my favorite books but I cannot bring myself to watch the movie. I think it is horrendous what that
director did to the movie.
I think all the other movies are great on their own, but when compared to the books most of the movies fall very short, mainly due to the time restraints. |
||
|
Rainbow05 |
|||
|
Posts: 180 (01/26/2009 2:24 AM) |
CoS isn't my favorite book, but I enjoyed the film. Now, I absolutely HATE HBP, but I cannot wait to see how the film turns out.
|
||
 doylefan2002 |
|||
|
Posts: 9380 (01/26/2009 9:25 AM) |
xlovinjt131x wrote: WTF? I love the OotP book and the movie. It would be impossible to have everything or almost everything in the book be included in the movie. You really have to separate the two versions and just enjoy them for what they are. |
||
|
Can Twins Have Two Fathers |
|||
|
Posts: 450 (01/26/2009 12:17 PM) |
It's okay if people don't like the movie you know.
|
||
|
angelittrell |
|||
|
Posts: 34346 (01/26/2009 2:02 PM) |
Least favorite book. PoA is my favorite book, and I was so glad I liked the movie.
 I loved that it was darker than the first two, it was more fitting.
|
||
|
jctime |
|||
|
Posts: 5 (01/26/2009 10:40 PM) |
Chamber of Secrets is okay, but I think Prisoner of Azkaban was one of the best movies, but I hated reading the book version. My favorite book in the entire
series is Goblet of Fire, but the movie version was awful. It broke my heart that the acting was so bad and scenes were chopped up. OoTP is great, both
versions!
|
||
|
Bunson3181 |
|||
|
Posts: 25810 (01/27/2009 4:53 PM) |
I'll agree that Chamber probably isn't my most favorite but I still enjoy it.
And I also agree if they cut certain things out of HBP I'll kill someone. Like Remus/Tonks needs to be there and the first actual appearance of Bill Weasley. |
||
|
xlovinjt131x |
|||
|
Posts: 383 (01/27/2009 6:54 PM) |
doylefan2002 wrote:It's not that they left out some things (although there were important parts that should have been in it) but they also blatantly changed some parts. I went with my brother who had not read the book and he was so confused. You had to read the book to get the story, but if you actually want the movie to resemble the book, this one did not. |
||
|
Gemini9857 |
|||
|
Posts: 23703 (01/27/2009 6:56 PM) |
My biggest problem with the movies is that they don't match up to the book well enough, IMO.
|
||
|
why you crying |
|||
|
Posts: 691 (01/27/2009 7:15 PM) |
They did change some things in OotP that I hated. Like the scene in the ministry and what happened with Ginny, that made me so mad. My cousins, who've
never read the book, all thought that Ginny was the best, smartest, most powerful witch/wizard at Hogwarts before I spent hours setting them straight about
things. That shit was so annoying and I'm so worried now because the same guy is directing the rest of the movies that he's gonna give all of
Neville's parts to Ginny in DH just to make her seem as amazing as JKR tried (and failed) to make her in the books.
|
||
