American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Shayme) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 23:54:11 GMT

Did I blame them for it every week? No. Making stuff up now? Really? Angel of Mine and My Prerogative were all him. When did anyone deny that? Plus, I really liked My Prerogative.

It shouldn't matter? Do you even watch the fucking show? Song choice is everything! You live and die by it on this show. You saying that is hilarious!

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (IHeartBaseballPlayersMucho) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 22:19:11 GMT

Seriously...Idol is the shadiest show EVER.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Shayme) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 22:05:05 GMT

vivalavix wrote:

RoCkJ03 wrote:
Conspiracy theories
It's cracking me up.

And if he's such a good singer getting "stuck" with Beat It shouldn't have been a problem, no?

I love that you people are acting like nothing...

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (IHeartBaseballPlayersMucho) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 21:55:04 GMT

It doesn't surprise me that Idol pulls the favoritism crap. It's pretty obvious who they want in the finals this year.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (The Very Bad Seed) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 21:49:10 GMT

RoCkJ03 wrote:

He kind of reminds me of Andy Gibb here.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (RoCkJ03) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 20:48:19 GMT

Conspiracy theories

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Sham99) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 20:43:24 GMT

^ Really?? I'm not surprised either.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Shayme) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 20:27:26 GMT

I can believe that. Someone on ONTD made a comment saying they heard Anoop was stuck with that song.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Sham99) — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 17:15:56 GMT

Jorge was on Regis and Kelly today and he said his first choice was not "Never can say goodbye." He had never heard of the song. He wanted to sing "You are not alone" but Michael Sarver got the song and the only ballad left was "Never can say goodbye" . This leads me to believe the producers give the good songs to the contestants they favor... they probably told Anoop to sing "Beat It"

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (lilo1231) — Sun, 15 Mar 2009 20:37:16 GMT

I think Danny DEFINITELY has a great voice. I think Anoop is very good, but I think its him who people are treating like the Second Coming.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Shayme) — Sun, 15 Mar 2009 16:07:06 GMT

He is an R&B singer. That's the kind of artist he is. He's very marketable. He's entertaining, has a good voice, and he has a great personality.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (HalfBloodPrince) — Sun, 15 Mar 2009 14:24:02 GMT

Yeah, Anoop has a good voice, but let's face it. Do you honestly picture many people going out of their way to buy his CDs? He's not marketable. I also can't picture what kind of "artist" he would be.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (nsync chica85) — Sun, 15 Mar 2009 09:09:42 GMT

I am really so confused by all the Anoop love.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (HalfBloodPrince) — Sat, 14 Mar 2009 22:53:30 GMT

The tween demographic who don't know anything about real talent act as if Danny is the second coming. Well considering they like Miley Cyrus and Jonas Brothers, I'm not surprised.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (HalfBloodPrince) — Sat, 14 Mar 2009 22:50:51 GMT

These singers have better voices than the overrated Danny....

Joe Anderson:

John Legend:

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (RoCkJ03) — Fri, 13 Mar 2009 11:58:59 GMT

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Daisy Duke) — Fri, 13 Mar 2009 08:37:43 GMT

Jaycie Fierce wrote:
I hate how he "WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"'s every time he gets good news. STFU! Your wife is still dead!

Wow! That is disgusting.

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Shayme) — Fri, 13 Mar 2009 01:30:19 GMT

I feel bad for Scott. They keep leaving him behind:

The show began, the Top 13 lip-synced and two-stepped through a Jackson 5 medley so bad it didn't even belong in a Christopher Guest movie, and Smirkelstiltskin perched himself on my collar-bone just in time to see the finalists move en masse to the couches and leave Scott MacIntyre behind, standing alone in the middle of the stage, presumably thanking his good fortune for never having to watch what he had...

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (guesswhatelse) — Fri, 13 Mar 2009 00:45:28 GMT

Sham99 wrote:
I feel really bad saying this but does anyone else think Scott may hold the rest of the group back when it comes to group performances. You could see this week he was struggling. Even if he wasn't blind, you could see he has no rhythm. I notice the other members have to hold him during group performances. I'm sure they don't mind. I know he's talented singer though. I just don't know how he...

Re: American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (PlaySka4me) — Fri, 13 Mar 2009 00:21:40 GMT

Sham99 wrote:

Yeah he never said they were in the bottom. He said "Jasmine I'm going to ask you to come to the center of the stage" "Kris have a seat.. Megan to the center of the stage" and "Megan you are safe" "Anoop.. go ahead" "Anoop you are safe"

Ok, so I am definitely thinking they were fucking with Anoop/the audience again.

American Idol - 3/11/09 - Two Are Eliminated from the Top 13

feeds@yuku.com (Showmeyoursoul) — Wed, 11 Mar 2009 08:43:21 GMT

So what do you think the twist is? Do you think it's that the judges choose one person to go home or do you think it's a singoff type of thing?